Last Updated on October 31, 2023 by Kelly
If you want to take a dip rather than a dive straight into the world of anal play, butt plugs are a great way to start. Think of plugs as a way to practice for deeper anal penetration.
You are training your body to have something in your butt before having anal sex or even before using a dildo.
You are teaching your sphincter how to relax when something is penetrating it.
Experimenting with butt plugs and backside play enhances the sexual experiences of anyone and everyone.
As a beginner, be sure to do prep work. You should select the right butt plug, ensure it’s properly lubricated, and clean up afterward.
In this article, I will give you some cleaning basics, how to prevent pain, and what lube works best for butt plugs.
Lastly, I will recommend some good beginner butt plugs.
Contents
What to Look for in a Starter Butt Plug
If you are new to butt plugs, you should look for specific features while shopping around.
Below are the listed traits and their explanations.
Small Size
Let’s begin by talking about butt plug sizes. Yes, smaller is better; a butt plug at around 1.25 inches in girth is a great starter size.
If you have used your fingers before, you may be able to take something a little bigger. Maybe give 1.5 inches a try; from there, you can creep your way up to bigger sizes.
You may notice some of the butt plugs are long and intimidating. But the longer sizes are not necessarily going to hurt.
They are designed to eventually build you up to stretching.
If you want to work your way up to bigger sizes, the longer sizes are for training your anus to take on something wider.
Tapered Tip
When a butt plug is thinner at the tip, insertion is easier and more comfortable.
Even with a tapped tip, take it slow and ease into it. Slow is the best way to go, no matter the size.
A tapered tip is a feature meant to avoid injury, but If you are impatient with your body, you may hurt yourself.
When this happens, what was supposed to be a pleasant experience can turn into an emergency room visit.
The thinner the tip, the easier insertion will be on your body. Once your body begins to relax, it will accept the plug, and you can introduce your bum to more girth.
But, again, take it slow and try just the tip first.
Flared Base
No matter how experienced you are with anal play, a flared base is important.
This flared base is essential because the anus has no natural stopping point, which means a butt plug or anything you insert can get sucked up and disappear inside you.
And that is not a trip to the doctor you want to take.
Avoid that awkward moment at the ER and get a plug with a wide base that will stay in place.
Wider plugs may become uncomfortable with prolonged use. However, you want that peace of mind, especially as a beginner.
Non-Porous Material
Avoid butt plugs made of porous materials because they allow substances and bodily fluids to be absorbed.
As a result, butt plugs made of porous materials are almost impossible to fully sanitize and clean.
Instead, look for toys made out of non-porous materials like Silicone, ABS Plastic, Glass, Metal, and Lacquered Wood.
Using these materials makes cleaning up a lot easier and stops your toy from getting smelly
Of course, being clean is super important with anal play.
Using a non-porous plug will help you avoid potential infections.
Also Read: How to Clean a Butt Plug Properly
And Don’t Forget to Lube Up
Lube is essential to all anal play because, unlike vaginal penetration, the anus does not naturally become wet. To avoid pain during your sexual journey, use a lot of lubrication.
The best lube for butt play is a lubricant designed specifically for anal. You can find lubricants with “anal lube” printed on the bottle.
Keep an eye out for these lubes.
They are best for anal play because they’re longer lasting, slicker, and give your bum a little more cushion when compared to normal lubes.
Because butt plugs are designed to be inserted for prolonged periods, long-lasting lubes are ideal for butt plugs.
I would personally recommend beginners to keep a plug in for no longer than 2-3 hours.
But if you use a great lube and the butt plug feels comfy, there is no need to set a time limit on your playtime.
See Also: The Main Variety of Plugs To Choose From
What Size Butt Plug Is Best for Beginners?
Going for a smaller butt plug is advisable if you’re doing anything to your bum for the first time.
A butt plug around 1.25 inches in girth is a great starter size.
If you have experience using fingers, you can try something bigger, like 1.5 inches.
What Are The Best Butt Plugs For Beginners?
BASICS Anal Play Butt Plug Kit (4 Piece)
All three toys in this beginner butt plug kit have 4 inches of insertable length with a maximum girth of 3.25 inches. Be sure to take it slow and use a lot of lube with these butt plugs.
Every butt plug in this kit has a suction cup on the end, making them great for hands-free solo play.
Butt plug kits should always be on a beginner’s shopping list, especially for those who don’t know where to start.
This kit has 3 different butt plugs, so you can experiment and see what works best for you.
Does the swooping P-spot butt plug have you tingling? What about the butt plug shaped like anal beads?
Insert this plug one groove at a time to give a gradual filling sensation. Don’t rush it. If you can only take one bead, start with that.
Or maybe your favorite could be the standard tapered butt plug that slowly fills you?
This kit also includes a douche to clean yourself out and reduce the chance of an embarrassing moment as you explore anal.
For first-time douche users, the solution used in the douche should be pH balanced, specifically for the bum.
It’s best to do douching for at least a few hours before any anal play. Be sure to avoid excessive douching. You want to feel cleaned out, but too much douching can cause health problems.
Pros
- All the butt plugs in this kit have a wide flared base to keep them from getting sucked up.
- Every toy is fully submersible.
- All 3 toys are smooth and tapered, gradually increasing in girth for easy insertion.
Cons
- The douche can be hard to squeeze.
Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug
This fluffy hot pink bunny tail is for those looking to fill up their butt and fulfill a kink.
It is also guaranteed to look cute poking out of your butt.
The butt plug has 2.5 inches of insertable length and 3.5 inches in circumference. It is made from non-porous silicone, which is pliable and comfortable, so it fits nicely in the tushy.
The fluffy bunny tail also adds a little tickle to your bum, enhancing the feeling of fullness the plug gives.
If you want to wear it outside the bedroom, you can hide the tail easily under a skirt.
Because of its bulbous shape and long stem, it will stay in place. It is perfect for walking around and showing off to your partner at home. Add a set of bunny ears to complete the look.
This cute butt plug is reasonably priced, making this purchase something you don’t have to justify. It’s waterproof, too, but the soaked tail won’t look as cute.
Pros
- The flared base keeps it securely in place once inserted.
- This toy is easy to insert
- Affordable in Price
Cons
- Cleaning up the tail can be difficult.
- The plug is short for some users.
LoveHoney Classic Silicone Beginner’s Butt Plug
This classic butt plug has a tapered end that slowly gets bigger in girth. Because of the gradual growth in girth, this butt plug is an excellent option for adventurous beginners.
The circumference is 3 inches at its biggest and 4 inches of insertable length. It also has a wide square base, ensuring the plug will not get sucked up.
It is made of hypoallergenic silicone. This butt plug is best used with a water-based lube. Using a silicone-based lubricant would cause it to deteriorate over time.
After putting this product to the test, we found that this plug is excellent for water play.
Opt for an oil-based lube if you try it yourself in the bath or shower. A water-based lube wouldn’t hold up well in water.
It is small enough for beginners and doesn’t look intimidating. Designed in a classic style, this butt plug makes a great introduction to the world of butt plugs.
It’s also an ideal butt plug to wear out in public. Great for amping yourself up for a big night while you are out buying groceries or even waiting in line.
It won’t get you in trouble as long as you don’t tell anyone it’s in there.
Pros
- The silicone is firm yet flexible, making it feel nice inside.
- Easy to clean.
- Beginner Friendly.
Cons
- The square base is a little big and can become uncomfortable if worn for a long time.
- This plug may be too small for some first-timers.
Best Vibrating Butt Plug For Beginners
Rocks off 7 Function Ass Berry Vibrating Butt Plug 2.25Inch
This cute berry shaped butt plug is 4.25 inches in circumference with 2.5 inches of insertable length. Its small size and affordable price make it a great vibrating butt plug for beginners.
Due to its tapered tip and small size, it’s easy to insert. Just be sure to use a water-based lube because this little guy is made of silicone.
A good feature of this device is its 7 different vibration modes.
After trying out this product, it’s clear that this buzzy berry does not disappoint.
Rocks off 7 Function Ass Berry Plug is battery-powered with a flared base to keep it in place. The ridges of the plug add extra sensation as you move around, brushing up on your insides just enough.
The exact shape of the bumps will vary since, like berries in nature, the bumps’ placement is not always in the same spot.
With its cute berry shape and the pink button poking out to control vibrations, this vibrator is great for solo and partner play. So lube this butt plug up, slip it in the right place, and enjoy the vibrations!
Pros
- Made with IntraMed hypoallergenic silicone, which makes cleaning up a breeze.
- Textured for extra sensation.
- Latex free and Phthalate-free.
Cons
- Not the most discreet vibrator. This butt plug vibrator is not a good option if you want the vibrations to be quiet.
- It can get you off too fast with the p-spot stimulation.
Best Beginner Butt Plug For Men
Njoy Pure Plug Small Stainless Steel Butt Plug
Njoy is a stainless steel butt plug that’s curved with a contoured bulb. This added design feature stimulates the male prostate, also known as the P-spot.
Targeting the p-spot during anal play is how men achieve their best orgasm. It is most commonly compared to a woman’s G-spot.
The P-spot can be found by inserting your finger about 2 inches into the anus and curling your fingers up towards the belly button.
This plug is designed for optimal pleasure for those with a penis. Its stainless steel material also adds a smooth and sensual sensation to your play.
This shiny, beautiful butt plug is a long-lasting addition to any sex toy collection.
Because of its stainless steel construction, this little beauty gives the user a sense of fullness and adds a sense of weight.
It is sized for beginners at 3 inches in total length and is 3.1 inches in circumference at its widest point. The Njoy Plug is also hand-polished to a mirror shine.
Included with the butt plug is a velvet-lined wooden box. This velvet-lined box is typical for Njoy products and works great to store your toy and keep it safe.
This shiny toy has a wide base with a handle to keep it from getting sucked up. Because this toy is made of high-quality steel, the clean-up process is easy.
Since this butt plug is made with steel, it can be used with any lubricant. No matter how slick a butt plug feels, always use lube!
Pros
- The plug is easy to insert because of the smoothness of the metal.
- It gives the user a pleasant feeling of fullness and has some weight, making it feel great inside.
- Stainless steel sex toys are great for temperature play.
Cons
- This toy is on the expensive side.
FAQ
How Should You Clean a Butt Plug?
Start by scrubbing the butt plug with soap and water to remove any remaining debris.
After that, sanitize the toy. Sanitizing a toy means getting rid of any remaining bacteria.
To do this, submerge the toy in boiling water for 3 minutes or put it in the dishwasher for a sanitizing cycle.
Do not fully submerge your toy if it is unsafe to put it underwater. In those cases, you can sanitize your toys with a bleach solution.
The solution should contain 4 tablespoons of bleach to a gallon of water. Spray the toy and let it sit for 10 minutes. Just be sure to wipe the solution off before use.
Are Butt Plugs Painful?
Mild discomfort isn’t unusual when using butt plugs, especially for beginners. But there is a difference between discomfort and pain to the point of injury.
Listen to your body if you are in pain, slow down, or change positions. Don’t go to the next step until you are very comfortable with the butt plug size you are using.
Take your time training with each plug before moving up to a larger size.
If you push through the pain, you might end up doing damage to your body. We want to minimize the possibility of tears and hemorrhoids.
Take your time; foreplay and relaxation are very important. Don’t try this while under time constraints.
Relaxing before inserting a butt plug is the best way to avoid pain.
You could drink some wine or even try orgasming before. Watch some porn while having that glass of wine. Whatever works for you.
Adding more lube could do the trick, or try positioning your body differently.
What Makes Butt Plugs Pleasurable?
Butt plugs are designed to give a filling sensation to the user and put pressure on the sensitive parts of your backside.
The orgasm you get from anal play is more intense than orgasms achieved through other means.
This is the case especially for men because butt plugs are shaped to stimulate men’s prostate.
As a result, men experience a different kind of orgasm than the one achieved with a penis.
A butt plug targets the prostate while you engage in other activities with yourself or your partner.
Just like men, women can also enjoy butt plugs as they go about their daily routines while it’s inserted.
And by putting pressure on the back vaginal wall, penetration is also much more enjoyable.
Which Lubricant Should I Use With Butt Plugs?
As the anus does not produce wetness naturally, lube is essential.
The lubricant you use should be compatible with the material that the plug is made out of. For example, if your butt plug is made of silicone, do not use a silicone-based lube.
The best lubricant to keep your eye out for is a lube that is specifically for anal use.
Anal lubes are designed to last longer and to give the bum more cushion and slickness than traditional lube.
Consider using an anal water-based lube with your butt plug because these lubes are compatible with all sex toys.