Homemade Butt Plug – How To Make Your Own DIY Toy

Last Updated on April 2, 2024 by Kelly

Have you ever considered making your own butt plug? If yes, this article may be just what you need.

You may think I’m crazy. Why would anyone want to try a homemade butt plug when they can buy one for $20 or less? 

Whether you’re a buttplug expert or a total newbie, a DIY anal plug is something to consider, but only if you do it correctly. 

I will show you how to make a homemade butt plug step by step. Read this article to find out all the steps.

Can You Make Your Own Butt Plug?

Yes, you can make your own butt plug! However, it won’t look like the commercially produced kind. Nevertheless, when it’s about pleasure, looks don’t matter so much, right?

So let’s discuss the easy options first, starting from your kitchen. 

Some vegetables work great as makeshift butt plugs. You should stick to the ones that look like a penis because not every vegetable is suitable for anal pleasure.

You can even try inserting fruits like a banana for some sweet pleasure. But what about vibrations? You can’t get them with fruits. 

Black butt plug in a females hand

Don’t worry; I have another cool option to spice up your masturbation round – A vibrating toothbrush!

If you’re excited to try an electric toothbrush, you MUST have some experience with anal masturbation beforehand. Otherwise, it may hurt and make you uncomfortable. 

If you want to get bold and create your very own butt plug, you should be familiar with glass blowing and pottery wheeling or know someone who does.

The process is easy but slightly technical as well. Anyway, I will discuss all the options above in detail later in this article. 

First, it’s more important to know the risks of using a DIY butt plug, so that you can take preventive measures. 

Safety First – Precautions to Take

Did you know that DIY butt plugs are more dangerous compared to other sex toys? I don’t want to scare you, but it’s necessary to know what you’re getting into. 

If you aren’t careful enough, your homemade plug will get stuck inside your ass. Forget pleasure; you’ll have to rush to the ER immediately for your safety. 

To avoid that, make sure you’re following the instructions properly.

Here are some things to keep in mind:


  • Your homemade butt plug should have a wider end to make pull-out easier.
  • No matter how experienced you’re in anal play, don’t start masturbating without lube.
  • Don’t use a tampon to masturbate as they’re made of cotton. It’s a big no!

If you’re just starting with anal play or butt plugs, it’s best to experiment with fingers before advancing onto plugs. Rimming is also a great way to get your body prepared for anal fun. 

Not only do rimming and fingers feel pleasurable, but they can help stretch you out before you insert any type of plug.

Do you want to give homemade butt plugs a shot? Let’s get straight into it!

How to Make a Buttplug at Home

If you are completely new to anal masturbation, you may not be ready to buy a buttplug kit. Maybe you want to experiment and see if anal play is something you like. 

Most people prefer anal sex for a change. But if you’re not used to anal stretching, you won’t enjoy anal sex. In fact, it can get painful as your rectum isn’t elastic like your vagina.

So the point is, anal sex isn’t a great idea if you’re an anal virgin. If you’re nervous to try butt plugs for some reason, you may feel confident with our DIY butt plug hacks. 

Luckily there a lot of alternatives to shop buttplugs. Some of them are even lying around in your home!

Here are some household items you can use to make a makeshift buttplug.


Shape Your DIY Buttplug With Silicone

Using silicone is an easy way to make your own homemade buttplug. Not only is it safe to use, but it’s also non-porous, which will keep your plug from smelling weird. 

Fortunately, there are plenty of clone-a-willy kits around to simplify the process. Although they are mainly designed for making dildos, they can also be used to create buttplugs.

A clone a willy butt plug kit

What size? You decide. You can go with what you like in terms of width and length. 

Make sure to give your anal plug a wide end so that you can pull it out easily.


Vegetables For a Healthy Sex Life

Vegetables don’t just help your health; they’re also great to use as makeshift buttplugs. 

Some fruits and vegetables like cucumbers and bananas have phallic shapes. In other words, they look like a penis. Therefore, you can use them as sex toys.

The next time you feel horny, ditch the salad and use that cucumber for some anal play.

You can also consider carrots to make your DIY butt plug. However, don’t forget to use a condom over the vegetable you choose, and don’t forget the lube. 

You may wonder, why is a condom necessary here? Well, your rectum is sensitive and may react to vegetables and fruits if you don’t practice safe masturbation. 

If you’re thinking of masturbating with a vegetable, you should first rub it against your palm to make it warm. Next, apply plenty of lubricant for smooth insertion. 

It’s better to start with a banana or carrot as they are comparatively softer than a cucumber. Once you’re comfortable, you can switch to cucumber for a deeper sensation. 

Remember: Don’t put the vegetables and fruits back in the fridge after using them 🙂


Toothbrush Vibrations

Do fruits and vegetables sound repulsive? Are you bored of using your fingers? 

If that’s the case, maybe a vibrating toothbrush can assist you.

A makeshift diy toouthbrush butt plug

What’s the right way to masturbate using a toothbrush? Start with your clit and move towards your asshole gradually. Wait for the pleasure to build!

You also won’t have to worry about your safety as toothbrushes are pretty long. They can create a unique sensation! 

If you’re a male looking to experiment with homemade plugs, this could be a great option. It gives pleasure by pressing against your p-spot.

The vibrating toothbrush is an excellent makeshift plug for both men and women, so get ready for some couple play. However, the rule of using a condom applies here as well. 


Ginger Root Fire

You might think it is unusual, but it works wonders! Ginger root as an anal plug can really spice up the pleasure.

In the past, ginger root anal penetration was used as punishment because of its burning sensation. This practice is known as figging! 

However, if you’re aroused and well lubricated, you will likely enjoy the pleasurable pain. 

The steps are pretty simple. 

Buy organic ginger. You will probably use a condom over it, so why does it matter? Well, it’s always best to stay on the safe side. Organic gingers come in multiple sizes, so you have lots of options to choose from. 

You can skip using a condom if you want to feel a tingling sensation.

Now, carve the ginger root into a plug shape. You don’t have to cut off the wider end for safety purposes; it will work as a flared base.


Candle Warmth

It’s time to look past candlelight dinners and start making a butt plug out of them. After all, candles come in all kinds of shapes and sizes. 

You don’t have to experiment with this all alone! It’s more fun with a partner.

Here is a quick process:


  • Pick a candle, ideally a longer one. 
  • Dip it in warm water to soften the wax. 
  • Once the wax is soft, you can easily shape the candle into a plug. Smoothen any sharp edges gently!

If you’re a first-timer, try keeping your candle buttplug short for easy insertion. 

After your candle plug is ready, put a condom over it, apply some lube, and insert slowly. 


Handle Your Umbrella 

Has an umbrella ever made you wet? If not, then try it my way! This tip might not be for everyone, though. 

But if you want to be creative, your broken umbrella may come in handy. You can remove the handle and use it as a DIY anal plug.

However, you have to find something to use as a makeshift handle. That’s the tricky part! But if you can manage to make it work, then voila! 

Precaution: Umbrella handles are quite hard since they are made of plastic or metal, so be generous with the lube and use a condom.


Finger Fun

Never underestimate your fingers! Fingering is the easiest way to enjoy anal pleasure and prepare your ass for penetration.

Sometimes fingers are all you need and can be much more useful than toys. You can experiment with your fingers or ask your partner to finger your ass. 

Make sure to use a lot of lube if you plan to take in more than two fingers. If you’re an experienced anal player, you can try fisting for a deep sensation. 

Your fingers can also help your ass accommodate bigger sex toys. They prepare your anus by slowly and gradually stretching it out.


Hire a Talented Glass Blower

Do you want something high-end? You can always hire a glassblower to make a glass plug! Glass butt plugs look elegant and are great for intense pleasure. 

Since glass isn’t a porous material, you don’t have to worry about any smell.

You can also make a glass plug on your own if you have glass blowing skills. Whether glass or silicone, your butt plug MUST have a wider end. 

This rule is mandatory for any butt plug!

Glass plugs are easy to clean, and you can make them into any shape and width. If you have time, consider making a fun handle as a precaution for safety. 


Hard Wood is Your Friend

Do you want to try something new? How about a wooden butt plug? 

If you have amazing woodworking skills, why not utilize them for your own pleasure? Or let a professional woodworker do it for you. 

For some people, a wooden butt plug isn’t a comfortable option due to splinters. You can fix this issue by coating the wood with high-quality polish. 

If you want something luxurious and durable, you’re right to go for a wooden butt plug. 

Carve the wood, preferably oak or pine, into your desired shape and size. For a smooth surface and sealed ends, it’s recommended to use a finishing varnish. 

If you aren’t confident about using wood near your sensitive areas, you can use a condom to ensure maximum protection. Also, since wood is hard, make sure to be gentle and well-lubricated.

Anyway, I mentioned pottery wheeling earlier in this article. You can use this technique to make a butt plug out of clay if you’re an expert. But is it safe? Not really. 

Clay is a porous material that can absorb bacteria and other germs. It’s good to stay away from it and use other DIY butt plugs instead.


Buy One Cheap for as Little as $10-$20

Do you want to get straight into anal masturbation? Then it’s best to stay away from the DIY hassle and simply buy a butt plug from a nearby sex toy store. 

Or you can order it online from a site that promises discreet packaging. 

Also Read:

Top All Day Butt Plug Choices (that have discreet packaging)

Make Your Own DIY Clit Sucker

Different Types of Butt Plugs To Choose

,

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge