Last Updated on October 4, 2023 by Kelly
So, you’ve been toying around with the idea of using a butt plug?
You’ll soon discover that there are different kinds of butt plugs distinguished by their materials.
And choosing between them can be a pain in the ass.
Of course, there’s a reason that metal butt plugs are so popular among anal play veterans. But we won’t reveal it just yet.
Keep reading to find out why 😉
Contents
What Are the Best Metal Butt Plugs?
Let’s have a look at the best metal butt plugs that are body-safe and super fun to explore.
We have also included a brief buying guide to help you make an informed decision!
LoveHoney Jeweled Metal Beginner’s Butt Plug
Who says beginners can’t enjoy both vitality and glamor in their newfound love of anal butt plugs?
The LoveHoney Jeweled Anal Plug proves that even first-timers can add a little pizzazz to their anal play sessions.
Also known as a princess plugs, jeweled metal butt plugs will indeed make you feel like royalty.
However, some butt plug beginners mistakenly feel like they need to stay as basic as possible.
And while we understand your apprehensions, we’d like to recommend this beginner-friendly jeweled toy.
We love the miniature-sized shape of this metal butt plug, which is 2.5 inches long, for beginners and professionals alike.
Not only is the smooth zinc alloy plug easy and painless to insert, but it’s also extremely comfortable for long-term wear around the house or even out in public.
But don’t let the small size of the butt plug fool you; while it may be tiny, it feels amazing, nevertheless.
With a hefty weight of 145 grams, wearing this bulky plug will make you feel full.
The slightest shift and turn will trigger waves of pleasure coursing throughout your body.
And while the LoveHoney Jeweled Metal Butt Plug is modest in its size, it’s far from modest in its design.
Of course, the star of the show is the silver jewel that adorns the base of the plug.
Everything about this embellished anal toy screams extravagance and makes for some great visual stimulation.
However, there’s more to this jeweled base than just aesthetics.
On the contrary, the flared base lends itself to an ergonomic design, which allows you to tug at it, move it, and take it out easily when you’re done.
Pros
- The size is ideal for beginners as well as anal play veterans for long-term wear.
- The jewel base provides visual stimulation for you and your partner.
- At only $26.99, it is excellent value for money.
Cons
- Some people might find the size to be too small.
- Zinc-alloy can trigger an allergic reaction, although it’s rare.
Rear Assets Small Jewelled Rose Gold Metal Butt Plug
Any fulfilling sexual experience is just as much about visual stimulation as physical and mental stimulation.
With that in mind, the Rear Assets Jewelled Rose Gold Metal Plug covers all fronts.
The Rear Assets Butt Plug boasts a beautiful and elegant rose gold finish.
The mere anticipation of using this stunning toy will fill you up with excitement.
To top it all off, a translucent pink jewel embellishes the flat base of the plug.
With such an eye-catching gem peeking through your cheeks, you can’t help but wiggle your butt so that the jewel catches the light.
This beginner-friendly butt plug is as small as they come at 1.75 inches. It’s crucial that first-timers start small and build up gradually.
So, anything under two inches is an excellent place to start.
But the real question is: how good does it feel?
If this is your first ever experience with anal play, the Rear Assets butt plug will definitely have you feeling weak in the knees.
It may be small, but this weighted metal butt plug will make you feel like you’re stuffed to the brim.
Moreover, it’s one of the easiest butt plugs to insert; the tapered tip slides inside your anus easily, even more so with just a little bit of lube.
In fact, you’ll find that a small amount of lube goes a long way with this butt plug. This means you can have uninterrupted and hassle-free anal fun.
Pros
- Ideal for beginners
- Rose Gold finish provides visual stimulation
- Super affordable
- Temperature-sensitive metal for temperature play
Con
- The size can be too small even for some beginners.
LoveHoney Jeweled Heart Medium Metal Butt Plug
If you’re looking to advance your butt plug adventures, the LoveHoney Jeweled Heart Metal Butt Plug will definitely take things up a few notches.
This eye-catching metal plug boasts a polished silver exterior that is so smooth that it is almost fully reflective.
But the real show-stopper is the heart-shaped pink jewel base. Beyond just being easy to hold, this cute heart-shaped design is more than easy on the eyes.
What’s more, this breathtaking butt plug feels just as good as it looks.
You can probably already guess that this large and weighted butt plug will hit all the right spots.
If small-sized butt plugs have lost their charm on you, this enormous anal toy will give you butterflies in your stomach.
But the sheer size of this butt plug doesn’t deserve all the credit.
Instead, the hefty weight of the stainless metal induces most of the pleasure.
With nearly 240 grams of dense metal stuffed inside your butt, you’ll have constant stimulation and endless pleasure.
The best part? The LoveHoney Jeweled Heart Butt Plug is entirely waterproof.
This means that you can use your favorite water-based lubricant without damaging the finish.
A word of advice: the name deceives you into thinking that the toy won’t be too intense.
However, don’t be fooled; even some pros might have trouble sliding the toy in fully, if at all.
With 3.5 inches of insertable length, that’s not a surprise.
Pros
- Best weighted rigid metal butt plug
- The heart-shaped jewel is glamorous and cute.
- A waterproof exterior allows you to use water-based lubricants.
Con
- The size and weight can be overwhelming even for pros.
nJoy Pure Plug O-Ring Base Butt Plug
A butt plug can only be as good as its base. Sure, the length, circumference, and weight matter. But they don’t matter as much as your control over the toy.
The standard base design for high-end butt plugs is flat and flared.
However, the nJoy Pure Plug goes one step further by equipping its metal butt plug with an O-ring.
Basically, you can hook your finger on the O-ring for a more secure grip.
Not only that, but you also have better control over how you navigate it inside your ass. Hence, you have complete control over which spots to hit based on what feels good.
And boy, does it feel good.
Unlike most metal butt plugs, the nJoy O-Ring plug has an angled head.
The angled head makes inserting the toy ten times easier. Once it’s in, this weighted butt plug is sure to elicit a moan or two.
The best part is that it comes in three sizes. So whether you’re a beginner or a pro, you’re likely to find the perfect fit for you.
Admittedly, the O-ring can create a stark outline in leggings and jeans, especially if you have a petite behind.
So, keep that unfortunate detail in mind if you’re thinking about wearing this butt plug out in public (but don’t let it stop you from doing so).
Pros
- O-Ring base makes sure the plug stays in place.
- Precise control over the toy once it’s in
- An angled head provides even greater stimulation both around and inside the anus.
Cons
- The O-Ring is visible through clothes for people with smaller behinds.
- Pricier than its competition
DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Medium Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug
Unleash your inner vixen with the Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug. This metal tail plug is perfect for power play in the bedroom and fulfills your exhibitionist fantasies.
The insertable section of the Dominix foxtail butt plug is made of stainless steel, which is a top-tier material for metal toys.
Not only is stainless steel generally safe, but it is also the most health-friendly choice of material.
But the best and often underrated aspect of stainless steel butt plugs is their temperature sensitivity.
For this reason, the Dominix metal butt plug is perfect for those couples or soloists who are into temperature play.
Of course, this foxtail anal toy also appeals to a more obvious kink: pet play and submission.
Think about it: no roleplay is complete without an ensemble— whether it’s restraining gear, costumes, or, in this case, a foxtail butt plug.
Pros
- This steel butt plug is ideal for temperature play.
- A tail butt plug adds a lot of excitement to your fun times.
- You can remove the tail from the plug to clean it.
Cons
- Not beginner-friendly
- The faux foxtail can become matted and flat over time
- The long stem makes it unsuitable for long-term wear
Are Metal Butt Plugs Safe?
If you’ve never had the pleasure of wearing a metal butt plug before, you’re probably a little apprehensive.
And the horror stories from people who have had less than ideal experiences certainly don’t help.
But rest assured, metal butt plugs are generally safe to wear.
In fact, metal butt plugs are much safer than their glass counterparts.
Admittedly, though, silicone butt plugs take the lead in terms of anal toy safety.
The Material
The first thing that you’d want to know is whether the material itself is safe.
Unfortunately, as much as we’d love to say that all metal anal toys are body-safe, the world isn’t that perfect.
You see, metal butt plugs are made from stainless steel, which gives them that smooth and shiny dazzle.
Stainless steel itself is entirely body-safe. As a matter of fact, it is the least likely of all materials to trigger an allergic reaction.
Unfortunately, some companies will cheap out and claim that the toy is pure stainless steel when in reality, it is just chrome-plated.
Then we have the less-popular aluminum alloys butt plugs.
Recently, scientists have been a little iffy about traces of aluminum in body products such as sunscreen.
The reason they’re so apprehensive is that aluminum is a pro-oxidant and can cause inflammation, cell breakdown, and, ultimately, skin cancer.
Hygiene
Disinfecting your anal toys before use and cleaning them after your anal play session is essential. Otherwise, you risk contracting some severe infections.
The best way to sterilize anything is by using high temperatures.
Specifically, you can submerge them in boiling water and let the high heat take care of all the germs, bacteria, and other chemicals.
Luckily, metal butt plugs are super easy to clean compared to silicone or glass alternatives.
Since metal is resistant to high heat levels, you can easily use the boiling water technique without compromising its shape or integrity.
Long-Term Wear
Metal butt plugs are the safest options for long-term wear.
Think about it: stainless steel is unbelievably smooth, which means that it can just slide right in without too much resistance from your anal muscles.
Less resistance means fewer chances of tearing or lacerations.
In addition, metal butt plugs don’t require as much lube as silicone and glass alternatives.
Hence, you can wear metal butt plugs for long periods without any potential risk to your anal muscles.
The Safety Verdict
With everything considered, high-quality metal butt plugs are more than safe for anal play.
Hence, when it comes to choosing the best metal butt plugs, pricier is always better.
With that said, it’s best if you do thorough research before you invest in a new metal butt plug.
Skimming through the listed specifications isn’t enough. Instead, you have to look for the exact materials that went into making a particular butt plug.
FAQ
What Are The Disadvantages of Using Metal Butt Plugs?
We’re all for metal butt plugs, but that doesn’t mean they don’t come with their share of disadvantages:
Cheap metal butt plugs can be dangerous, and companies aren’t always transparent about the metals present in the plug.
Metal butt plugs are dense and heavy by default.
While some people enjoy this heavy feeling, others feel it is a little too intense and uncomfortable.
Metal butt plugs are pretty rigid, which can feel overwhelming for beginners.
By contrast, silicone butt plugs are much more flexible and can easily twist or bend for smoother insertion.
How Do Metal Butt Plugs Compare to Silicone Butt Plugs?
Silicone is the most popular choice of material among amateurs and professionals alike. However, metal butt plugs have their own charm.
In terms of safety, silicone butt plugs are often thought to be more superior.
However, this is only based on the assumption that metal butt plugs aren’t always what they claim to be, i.e., stainless steel.
Silicone has a clear lead when it comes to versatility.
While metal butt plugs are always dense and rigid, silicone butt plugs fall in a spectrum from rock hard to pillow-soft.
Consequently, silicone butt plugs are often flexible. You can find the best insertion angles and wiggle the toy around to find the optimal spot(s).
But don’t brush off metal butt plugs just yet.
Some people prefer the hefty, smooth, and rigid feeling of a metal butt plug. And who knows, you might too!
In addition, you can only use water-based lubes if you’re using a silicone butt plug to keep it durable and functional.
As a result, you may have to reapply the water-based lube multiple times as it quickly dries off.
Are Metal Butt Plugs Good For Beginners?
Some beginners find that metal butt plugs are heavier and therefore too intense for their first few times.
However, you shouldn’t feel uncomfortable as long as you take it slow and wear the plug only inside the bedroom for now.
Another point of concern is that metal butt plugs are perfectly rigid without the slightest give.
This rigidity can make things challenging during insertion and even more challenging once the toy is inside you.
That being said, rigidity is precisely what some people go after. Silicone butt plugs can be a little too bendy and feel a little flimsy.
By contrast, firm metal butt plugs feel much more substantial and secure inside you.
What’s The Best Base For a Metal Butt Plug?
Generally speaking, butt plugs have two different types of base designs: rounded base and tapered base.
Each category, in turn, has multiple subcategories of base designs, and it isn’t easy to crown any particular base as the best one.
But between rounded bases and tapered bases, the former wins by a landslide.
The thing with metal butt plugs is that you need a lot of control over these weighty toys.
Luckily, tapered bases help you hold the toy properly from any angle.
Moreover, the tapered base prevents the smooth and slick toy from sliding inside you completely.
Therefore, always look for a butt plug with a flat and broad base for a comfortable grip.